Opinion: Give President Obama A Vote On The Vacated Black Robe Or Don Your Closeted White Robe

  • by: Trendolizer

By Craig Hardegree

Hyper-partisan politics are not new. Political posturing is not new. The utter hatred of a president by the opposite party is not new. The country being deeply divided is not new. Having a divisive president is not new.

What's new is questioning a president's patriotism. What's new is questioning whether a president is a "true American." What's new is questioning a president's allegiance to the Constitution and his loyalty to the country. What's new is questioning whether a president is "one of us." What's new is screaming about "taking our country back."

What's new is congressional leaders from the opposing party meeting on the night of a president's inauguration and vowing to oppose him on everything, sight unseen, even if they actually agree with him.

What's new is members of the Senate Judiciary Committee announcing - before a president has ever nominated a person to fill a Supreme Court vacancy - that they will not even consider a nominee, regardless of qualifications.

Politically, we are at point which is virtually identical to where we were in 1988 when the Senate gave Reagan a hearing, during his final year in office, on his 3rd appointment to the Supreme Court.


  • 1988 vacancy
    After being out of power for six years, Democrats regained control of the Senate in 1986, with two years remaining in Republican Reagan's second term. Democrats controlled 55 seats.
  • 2016 vacancy
    After being out of power for eight years, Republicans regained control of the Senate in 2014, with two years remaining in Democrat Obama's second term. Republicans controlled 54 seats.


  • 1988 vacancy
    At the same time Democrats regained control of the Senate with two years remaining in Reagan's second term, the Democrats captured 258 seats in the House of Representatives, leaving the Republicans with 177.
  • 2016 vacancy
    At the same time Republicans regained control of the Senate with two years remaining in Obama's second term, the Republicans captured 246 seats in the House of Representatives, leaving the Democrats with 189.

Supreme Court appointment

  • 1988 vacancy
    Reagan made his third appointment to the Supreme Court with approximately a year left in office.
  • 2016 vacancy
    Obama will make his third appointment to the Supreme Court with approximately a year left in office.

Presidential approval rating

  • 1988 vacancy
    Reagan's approval rating in February 1988 was 52%.
  • 2016 vacancy
    Obama's approval rating for February 2016 is 50%.

Presidential divisiveness

2016 vacancy
President Obama has been very divisive. Not because of anything he has done or not done. Not because of the content of his heart.

It was the color of his skin.

1988 vacancy
Reagan was extremely divisive. But he chose to be. He sowed racial discord and fanned the flames of Southern racismintentionally, as a studied political strategy, to create a movement - an insurgency of near-rabid loyalists birthed out of the same irrational fear and God-condemned pride and feelings of superiority that gave rise to the Confederacy. And the Third Reich.

He also introduced social wedge-issues to divide churched and unchurched and blamed the poor for their plight, pitting the haves against the have-nots.

Presidential integrity

2016 vacancy
Conservatives have spent seven years desperately trying to conjure-up a scandal they could hang on President Obama but they have been profoundly unsuccessful because of his impeccable character and fastidious morals.

1988 vacancy
A week after the 1986 election which brought Democrats back to power in the Senate, Reagan interrupted regular programming with a live address from the Oval Office to solemnly and repeatedly vow to the American public that he did not sell weapons to Iran in exchange for the release of hostages.

Four months later, only eight months before naming his third Supreme Court appointment, Reagan returned to the living rooms of we-the-people for a second live address from the Oval Office, this time to admit - in a deal worked out to avoid impeachment - that his address to the American public four months earlier was a lie; that he had sold weapons to Iran in violation of the arms embargo; that he had done it behind the backs of the American public; that he had negotiated with terrorists for the release of American hostages and lied about doing it.

And yet...

Democrats held hearings in the Senate and eventually approved Reagan's third appointment to the Supreme Court, with only 11 months to go before Reagan would be out of office.

Yes, Democrats voted-down Reagan's first two suggestions for his third appointment to the court. And, yes, Democrats started the modern-day all-out war and circus over Supreme Court nominees with the hearings they held on Robert Bork. In the space of three weeks, Reagan nominated Robert Bork, then Douglas Ginsberg, both of whom were voted-down by the Democrats before they finally approved Anthony Kennedy.

But the Democratic senators interviewed each of Reagan's picks. The Democrat-controlled Senate Committee on the Judiciary considered each of Reagan's picks. The full Senate with a Democrat majority which was put into power by the people who had grown weary of Reagan's presidency, held hearings on each of Reagan's picks.

The 2016 equities between the parties are virtually identical to 1988, only reversed. The glaring differences between now and then all favor President Obama: President Obama didn't lie to the American public; President Obama wasn't forced to humiliate himself on live national television to avoid impeachment; President Obama did not intentionally instigate racial division, partisan division, religious division, economic division.

And President Obama has the strongest mandate-to-govern of any president in history:

  • In 112 years, only three presidents have been elected twice with 51% of the popular vote each time: Franklin D. Roosevelt; Dwight Eisenhower; President Obama. Not Bush, not Clinton, not Reagan.
  • President Obama received the most votes of any president in the entire history of the United States in 2008. The president receiving the second-highest number of votes was President Obama in 2012.
  • Since the founding of the Republican Party, only 9 presidents have been elected with coattails strong enough to propel the president's party into a 60-seat majority in the Senate and 59% or greater majority in the House. Abraham Lincoln was the first; President Obama was the last. And the 7 in between did not include Bush, Clinton or Reagan.
  • Large crowds are being used today as a measure of strength and popularity. Candidate Obama drew 100,000 at the Gateway Arch, 100,000 at a morning rally in Denver followed by 45,000 at Colorado State that same afternoon. Trump and Bernie haven't touched his records. President Obama drew 84,000 to his speech accepting the Democratic Party nomination, the largest in history for any acceptance speech. He drew 1.8 million to his inauguration, compared to 500,000 each for Bush II and Reagan and 800,000 for Clinton. He drew 200,000 at the Berlin Wall, compared to the 45,000 attending Reagan's fabled "Tear down this wall" speech.

There's no reason left to deny President Obama this historic opportunity, other than the color of his skin. Either give him a vote to fill the vacated black robe, or don your closeted white robe.

Craig Hardegree is a practicing attorney and passionate blogger for social justice in the Deep South. His educational background is in Sociology and religious background in evangelical fundamentalism. This was first published on his blog HeartAgree.

More news

Trendolizer™ Trending News Tracker

FREE: Get the most trending items found on the web by Trendolizer™ delivered to your inbox weekly

Most read


Like or Follow us to get the latest!