Just Because It's Trending Doesn't Mean It's True
Opinion

Opinion: Iran Nuclear Deal Opposition: 'Dirty Hands'

  • by: Raphael Sassower
  • (Fri, 07 Aug 2015 13:03:30 Z)

Just between observing the 70th anniversary of the dropping of the first atomic bomb on Hiroshima, Japan (August 6, 1945) and the second dropped on the city of Nagasaki (August 9, 1945), the Republican presidential candidates reiterated in unison their vehement contempt for the Iran deal to prevent it from building nuclear weapons. Instead of framing their outrage in moral terms or global disarmament terms, they merely want Iran not to have nuclear capability.

The fact that the United States is still spending billions annually to develop and build nuclear bombs wasn't even mentioned. The first presidential debate saw the seamless mixture of a commitment to increasing the military budget and confessions of faith, enlisting divine intervention in America's military might and global leadership.

The candidates' misguided outrage against President Obama shouldn't be about his weak negotiation skills with Iran, as some of them claim, but rather about his inconsistent, even hypocritical stance on nuclear weapons. While pledging in 2013 to reduce our nuclear arsenal and bring down nuclear weapon stockpiles around the world (meaning primarily Russia) he keeps authorizing billions of dollars in nuclear weapon spending, as is evident in the booming economy of Los Alamos, New Mexico.

Does this sound like a Democratic capitulation to global nuclear threats? Has this Democratic president veered even slightly from his Republican predecessor's hawkish stance? Would any American president dare challenge the military-industrial-academic complex that spends annually more than the entire world combined on its military might?

All of this reminds me of Jean Paul Sartre's play "Dirty Hands" (1948) where intrigue and treachery are exposed as the way political maneuvers are bound to unfold over time, and where a straight-forward moral judgment is difficult to come by. The context of the play was World War II and the flirting of communist regimes with fascist Nazi Germany. Today's realpolitik is cast similarly in terms of friends and foes, democratic regimes versus "Islamofascists," where the moral high-ground can be asserted in unequivocal political terms.

Does anyone seriously believe that a declaration of war against Iran will bring to an end tensions in the Middle-East? Are those who believe that the only way to handle Middle-East unrest is with another war willing to personally participate in it, and if too old, send their sons and daughters?

Amidst this debate over nuclear threats, we should acknowledge the only nation ever to have actually used a nuclear bomb has been the United States, not once, but twice, killing more than 200,000 people, primarily civilians. Was this the only way to end the Japanese threat?

The debate decades later is still not settled. But it is this nation's Republican candidates for the presidency who, without a historical perspective or any sense of guilt or shame, lecture the rest of the world on the danger of Iran's nuclear program. Whose hands are "dirty" after all?

Also read Prof. Sassower's Stop The Hypocrisy: Politics Of Iran Nuclear Deal and Opinion: The Age of Distraction.

Thumbnail image for Raphael Sassower profile.jpegRaphael Sassower is philosophy chair at the University of Colorado, Colorado Springs. Prof. Sassower's latest books are Compromising the Ideals of Science (2015), The Price of Public Intellectuals (2014), and Sports and Religion in American Culture (2014, with Jeff Scholes). He grew up in Israel and moved to the United States as a young man after serving as an officer in the IDF.

Lead Stories' Trendolizer scours social nets worldwide to identify and serve to you the hottest stories about Iran's nuclear program. Scroll down to see the latest.

About the author:

sassower.jpgRaphael Sassower is philosophy chair at the University of Colorado, Colorado Springs. Prof. Sassower's latest books are Compromising the Ideals of Science (2015), The Price of Public Intellectuals (2014), and Sports and Religion in American Culture (2014, with Jeff Scholes). He grew up in Israel and moved to the United States as a young man after serving as an officer in the IDF.

Read more about or contact Raphael Sassower
  • 検索できないバンド「アクメ」 / 絶唱謳歌【MV】

    1st album「絶唱謳歌」収録リードトラック「絶唱謳歌」ミュージックビデオ フル解禁 2018年8月8日(水)アクメ 1st album「絶唱謳歌」 「絶唱し謳歌するのが人生」 まもなく始動から1年を迎えるアクメ、初リリースとなるフルアルバムはなんと全10曲全て新トラック。 楽曲センスと確かなテクニックをさらにパワーアップさせた彼らの最新トラックの乱れ打ちを体感せよ。 リードトラック「絶唱謳歌」は夏ソングに定評のある(!?)CHISA&将吾とRIKITO、HALの超絶テクが光る 超待望の最新の夏ソング、これが日本の夏アクメの夏だ! ■リリース情報 1st Album 『絶唱謳歌』 【初回盤】 DCCNM-506 ¥3,500+税 ※着せ替え顔ジャケット付、1000枚限定  【通常盤】 DCCNM-507 ¥3,000+税 ※楽譜付 2018/8/8 Release   収録曲: 01.Paradox 02.絶唱謳歌 03.罵詈雑言 04.懐色花火 05.君の臓器になりたい 06.金欠マイレージ 07.MELODY(album ver.) 08.アナザーワールド 09.RUN 10.ADVENTURE TIME     ■ライブ情報 アクメ/1st ... -- https://www.youtube.com
    • 29 likes (29/hr)
    • 0 comments (0/hr)
  • Sign NIAC's Open Letter to Secretary Pompeo

    Sign this open letter to urge Pompeo to cease all efforts to destabilize Iran, repeating the costly mistake the US committed in Iraq. If the Trump administration truly wishes to help the people of Iran, they should lift the Travel ... -- https://www.niacouncil.org
    • 346 likes (23/hr)
    • 0 comments (0/hr)
  • WOODONE Kendama World Cup Hatsukaichi2018【Day 2】

    ウッドワン けん玉ワールドカップ廿日市 2018 7月21日・22日開催。 今年は世界の18の国と地域から、総勢400名以上の選手が、けん玉の発祥の地 廿日市に集い、優勝賞金150万円とトロフィーをかけたKendama世界頂上決戦を繰り広げる! Kendama World Cup Hatsukaichi 2018 is going to be on the 21st and 22nd July in Hatsukaichi city, Hiroshima Japan. Over 400 players from 18 countries and reigions will be competing for one of ... -- https://www.youtube.com
    • 26 likes (4/hr)
    • 0 comments (0/hr)
  • Netanyahu Brags About Controlling Trump - Media Silent

    In a leaked tape, Benjamin Netanyahu boasts about making Trump pull out of the Iran Nuclear Deal. This will not make the evening news. Here's How You Can Support Our Show & Independent Media! ▶ Check Us Out On Steemit ... -- https://www.youtube.com
    • 1699 likes (2/hr)
    • 0 comments (0/hr)

About Lead Stories

Lead Stories uses the Trendolizer™ engine to detect the most trending stories from known fake news, satire and prank websites and tries to debunk them as fast as possible. Read more about how we work and how we select stories to check here.

Spotted a hoax that you think we should investigate? Have a tip? Want to send us a correction? Contact us!

You can also follow us here:

Most read

Recent

Like or Follow us to get the latest!

NEW! Subscribe to our YouTube channel: